The primary goal of Waldorf education is not to mould adolescents into useful members of society. Through education, adolescents should above all learn what they need to be able to take an interest in people and the earth independently and in freedom. A contribution from Albrecht Schad, Henning Kullak-Ublick and Christof Wiechert.
After the end of the First World War, Europe lay in ruins. In November 1918, Emil Molt had a stopover in Dornach when he heard Rudolf Steiner say in a lecture that what was now required was to listen carefully to what the circumstances demanded (Leber, St., 2002). During a conversation with Molt in January 1919 about what needed to be done, Steiner mentioned that schools should be founded. On 23 April 1919, Molt summoned Steiner to take charge of a new school that was to be established. On 30 May, Molt acquired Café Uhlandshöhe and its grounds from his private funds. From 20 August to 5 September 1919, Rudolf Steiner delivered 14 lectures entitled «Allgemeine Menschenkunde als Grundlage der Pädagogik» (in English General Knowledge of the Human Being as a Basis for Pedagogy, published under «Practical Advice to teachers» (archive.org)), discussed methodological and didactic questions, and conducted seminars with 25 selected individuals, twelve of whom would later form the founding faculty. On 7 September, the opening ceremony of the Waldorf School took place in the municipal garden of Bad Cannstatt. And like this, out of a perception of the necessities of the time, the Waldorf School was founded at a breathtaking pace within a few months (see also Schad, A., 2018).
What is interesting to look at is how Rudolf Steiner responded to the perception of the necessities of the time. Many people were traumatised by the events of the war, and many had health issues. There was great hardship. However, Steiner did not respond directly to these contemporary difficulties. In contrast, many of his contemporaries also wanted to provide answers to the necessities of the time, even in the years before the First World War. Steiner, however, already remarked in 1907 in his short work «The Education of the Child» (Die Erziehung des Kindes): «Anyone who wants to make proposals about how things should be done in the future must not be content with merely getting to know life on its surface. They must explore it in its depths.» (Steiner, R., 1907). And then it continues: «The task of providing a comprehensive practical world-view that encompasses the being of human life must fundamentally belong to spiritual science. …Because these prerequisites are rooted solely in true knowledge of life. Whoever knows life will be able to set their tasks only from within life itself. They will not establish arbitrary programmes, for they know that no fundamental laws of life will prevail in the future that are different from those in the present. Therefore, spiritual research will necessarily be marked by respect for what already exists. However much it finds in need of improvement, it will not fail to see the seeds of the future within the existing order. It is for this reason that spiritual-scientific insight into the nature of humanity must provide the most fruitful and practical means for addressing the most important questions of contemporary life» (Steiner, R., 1907).
The above quote speaks of the humanistic deepening into the being of the human. In 1923, Steiner stated that Anthroposophy «merely aims to be a method of inquiry into the universally human and the general phenomena of the world» (Steiner, R., 1991). The title «General Knowledge of the Human Being as a Basis for Education» also indicates that these lectures do not describe the development of a specific individual nor the development of a person from a particular country or continent. Instead, Steiner addresses the being of the human, the «commonality» of humankind. He describes what connects all people on earth: the development of the potential inherent to all humans, regardless of their ethnic, cultural, religious, or socio-economic background and circumstances. Waldorf education can be practised anywhere on earth because we are genuine, fully-fledged, equal human beings everywhere on earth. Only once it comes to each specific individual can we begin to differentiate particularities physically related to gender, geographical origin, and cultural and religious circumstances.
Long before the Waldorf School's founding, Rudolf Steiner intensively researched the connection between the soul and the physical body. He was able to resolve this question after discovering the threefold nature of the human body. In 1917, he outlined this connection in a few pages in the appendix of the book «Riddles of the Soul» (Von Seelenrätseln): Thinking is based on the nervous system, which is widely recognised today. Feeling has as its physical basis the organs of the middle system, respiration and cardiovascular system, which work rhythmically throughout life. And willing is based on the metabolic organs of the abdomen and the limbs. In thinking, we can be fully awake; in feeling, we operate more in a dreamlike state of consciousness; and willing as an activity is not consciously experienced but only «in that very dull (state) that is present in sleep» (Steiner, R., 1917, p. 153). Steiner emphasised that this is not a threefold-division of the human being but a functional articulation, whose processes work differently in all organs yet manifest clearly in the described structure of the body. This discovery was further developed in later works (Schad, W., 2012).
In the previously mentioned work «The Education of the Child in the Light of Spiritual Science» (Die Erziehung des Kindes vom Gesichtspunkte der Geisteswissenschaft), it is stated that humans develop in seven-year rhythms. However, this concept is notably absent in today's developmental psychology. This raises the question: how can we interpret this? In a lecture given on 16 April 1912 (Steiner, R., 1912), Steiner emphasised that human beings do not develop in a rigid seven-year cycle, but rather that understanding and applying the successive stages of development is a pedagogical task in the education of children and adolescents (Schad, A., 2012). «But if, with the help of the educating adults, the connection to this seven-year rhythm is found, then individual destiny can reconnect with what unites all humans: that is, with humaneness» (Schad, W., 1992). It is, thus, a cultural task and act to divide human life into seven-year cycles: it is about the perception of biographical developmental stages in the successive appropriation of the world by children and adolescents, which are common to all people despite their individual characteristics. This has a supportive and comforting effect on the biography. Moreover, the rhythm of seven can, in some instances, be observed in biographies (Wiechert, Ch., 2020).
Throughout history, truth, beauty, and goodness have been cited as the three great unifying ideals in the conscious development of humanity. In a lecture in January 1923, Steiner explained that the virtue of goodness is related to the soul, the virtue of beauty to the beauty of the living realm, and the virtue of truth to the physical body (Steiner, R., 1923).
How is this to be understood?
When a child is born, it initially lives entirely in imitation of its surroundings. The child lives with the unconscious presumption that the world is moral and, therefore, fundamentally good. This is the great achievement of young children: believing in the world’s morality. Consequently, they can also believe that the world can be imitated. «Thus, the young child is a revelation of the prenatal, the spiritual-soul world. The young child, therefore, still lives in the reverberation of the prenatal, in the past» (Schad, A., 2007). An ideal of Waldorf education is that children are supported to imitate the world in the first seven years of life by being role models for them.
Between teething and puberty, particularly intensively between the ages of 10 and 12, the child lives with the unconscious assumption that the world is beautiful. It wants to find the world beautiful, and it wants to enjoy the world. It lives entirely in the present. Therefore, we should not fail to structure the lessons so that the children can enjoy them and not, for example, so that they evoke disgust and antipathy in the child. However, there is a risk that this principle of making teaching a source of joy and enjoyment can easily be distorted into sentimentality – Steiner called this «hausbacken» (home-baked, ordinary) in his first teacher training course. This can be avoided if the teacher cultivates an intensive relationship with art and the lessons become particularly artistic in this second seven-year period. A closer look at the artistic element in the second septennium brings a kind of differentiation to the fore. Especially at the beginning of school, when children are learning the cultural techniques, a certain sobriety is allowed to prevail – sober, not cold. In contrast, Steiner hoped that later, all teaching and all didactics would be immersed in a wealth of imagination, creativity and originality. In prepuberty, the children’s intellect awakens. An imaginative pedagogy nourishes this intellect so that instead of fuelling self-centredness, it awakens astonishment in the world (see also the last two pages of the last lecture of General Anthropology /Allgemeine Menschenkunde), Steiner, R., 1919).
With puberty, the relationship of adolescents to the world begins to change. They live with the unconscious assumption: the world is true. Now, the teaching should take on a scientific character. If we want to follow Steiner’s statement that truth has a special relationship to the physical body, an inner concept of truth can arise particularly through natural-scientific education, «I can understand the world through thought». The first step towards this is learning to observe and describe accurately to perceive things as they are and not as they suit us or are pleasant. In the third septennium, we support adolescents in their need to discover the truthful aspect of the world. Due to the sheer volume of secondary literature on the subjects taught, and the curriculum guidelines, the original curriculum has sometimes been lost sight of. If, however, one looks again at the early curriculum guidelines, e.g. Karl Stockmeyer’s work on Steiner’s curriculum suggestions, it becomes clear that the curriculum from the 6th school year onwards has a clear focus on natural sciences.
4th grade: Zoology
5th grade: Zoology, Botany
6th grade: Botany, Geology, Physics
7th grade: Chemistry, Mechanics, Algebra, Celestology, Anthropology
8th grade: Chemistry, Physics, History of technological developments, Anthropology
This curriculum can be interpreted as a reflection of the development of the generally human. What becomes apparent is that the world and humans belong together, and because of this, a natural ecological awareness can be awakened. It is becoming increasingly important to realise the curriculum in such a way that humans and the world are reconciled, that is, that the curriculum supports pupils in encountering the world in such a way that the interconnection between the world and humans can be expressed in acting responsibly: Responsibly towards others and responsibly towards the world. If you want to learn more about this interconnection, look at the book ‘Vom Leben unserer Erde’ (On the Life of our Earth) (Schad, A., 2023).
In upper school, then, scientific cognition comes to the fore. Goethe lists the qualities needed for scientific work (Goethe, J. W., 1793):
All subjects in the upper school at a Waldorf school contribute to acquiring and cultivating these important qualities, including the arts and crafts subjects. Learning and actively engaging these qualities provide adolescents with a kind of emotional-soul framework, the cultivation of which supports them in surviving these difficult years. The search for the meaning of one’s life and purpose in the world is intensively accompanied and supported in all subjects in upper school. It is not enough to simply complete many internships outside of school or to take walks in the forest.
Humans, like all animals, develop physically from top to bottom. This shows that we are part of the general evolution of animals, which are related to us as brothers and sisters (Schad, A., 2019). Let us again take a closer look at the development of the child. Particularly during embryonic development, but also during the first years of life until the dentition changes, the head is ahead in its development. It is disproportionately large compared to the chest or the metabolic-limb human. The child develops from the head outward. It is «particularly the head organisation, the nerve-sense organisation, that is active. ... and it is from the head that all growth and everything proceeds.» (Steiner, R., 1924, p. 116).
In this lecture, Steiner also points out that between the ages of 7 and 14, the child is wholly dictated by the rhythm of its breathing and the rhythm of its blood circulation. It is ‘entirely rhythm’. What does this mean for the practical organisation of lessons at a Waldorf school? Let us listen to Steiner once again:‘Now, in education and teaching, you have to turn to the system that governs human beings. So between the dentition change and sexual maturity, you must appeal to rhythm through imagery. You have to organise everything you describe, everything you do, in such a way that the head is involved as little as possible, that instead the heart, the whole rhythm, everything that is artistic, rhythmic, is involved. What is the result? That such teaching does not tire the child at all, because the focus is on the rhythmic system and not on the head’ (Steiner, R., 1924, p. 217). What is said in the following paragraphs of this lecture can be summarised by saying that good teaching has a healing and harmonising effect on children.
Rudolf Steiner was intimately familiar with the lived reality in the everyday life of the Uhlandshöhe Waldorf School through many visits in the years following its founding until his death. He was certainly not in agreement with everything he observed. Therefore, in many lectures, he attempted to «steer» or adjust, such as in his lectures from April 8th to 11th, 1924, at the Gustav-Siegle-Haus in Stuttgart (Steiner, R., 1974). Once again, he tried to «call out» to the young teaching staff, emphasising what he believed was central. He repeatedly pointed out in these lectures how important it is to consider the character of the three stages of life described above and to teach from an understanding of them.
Several pedagogical reform initiatives took place during the Weimar era and even before the school’s founding in 1919. However, there was hardly any exchange with other directions. The Wandervogel movement, in which my grandmother was involved, advocated hiking in nature and experiencing nature in the community. Steiner did not incorporate this at all. «Steiner was not much kinder to the rural educational homes, which he credited with good intentions but also accused of being ’a complete misunderstanding of what needs to happen for the culture of the future’» (Steiner, R., 1919/1932, 1992, p. 74) (Frielingsdorf, V., 2019, p. 77). Representatives of the rural educational homes had strongly advised Steiner to place the Waldorf school in unspoilt natural surroundings. Steiner’s answer to this (in analogy): «Where the need is greatest, in the cities, that is where the new schools belong. And anyone who thinks that city folk have to go to the countryside to find true life there is mistaken, because they take their city life with them. This only changes the outer shell, but nothing is solved.» (Schad, W., 1994).
Interestingly, Steiner does not take up the demands of his contemporaries but establishes Waldorf education as an independent impulse. The focus here is to support children in their incarnation journey through the curriculum, but above all through the teaching method (Frielingsdorf, V., 2019, p. 69). Successful teaching has a healing effect by taking into account the physical, emotional (soul) and intellectual (spirit) development of children (see also Zdražil, T., 2000). Establishing a connection with the world happens first and foremost through the children’s own doing (kindergarten and early school years) and then through the emotional or soul connection with the world, which, of course, also requires a lot of initiative and in upper school all the experiences and new perspectives acquired in this way are consciously penetrated through thinking. This concept remains completely independent to this day. However, it is increasingly supported by modern developmental and learning research (see Fuchs, Th., 2023).
The central task of education is to support children and adolescents in connecting their souls and spirits with their bodies. This is a complicated process that spans over two decades. The following could be mentioned as central aspects of Waldorf education:
With the founding of the Waldorf School, there was hope that schools would be released from the state’s custody and control because the needed innovations and impulses could only come from liberated contexts, from free spiritual life. Youth should not be educated to become utile, productive members of society; instead, through education, they should acquire what they need to be interested in and, if they choose, engage independently and freely for humanity and the earth.
Of course, it depends on the creativity and inventiveness of colleagues in many countries worldwide, who have become independent through their knowledge of Waldorf education and who work together on the questions and tasks of education.
Albrecht Schad, Henning Kullak-Ublick and Christof Wiechert
Bibliography:
Frielingsdorf, Volker (2019): Geschichte der Waldorfpädagogik. S. 77. Beltz Verlag.
Fuchs, Thomas (2023): World Teachers’ Conference 2023
Goethe, J. W. (1793): Naturwissenschaftliche Schriften, Zitat aus der Abhandlung «Der Versuch als Vermittler von Objekt und Subjekt»
Leber, Stephan (2002): Kommentar zu Rudolf Steiners Vorträgen über Allgemeine Menschenkunde als Grundlage der Pädagogik. Bd., S. 13. Verlag Freies Geistesleben.
Schad, Albrecht (2007): Zum Bildungswert der Naturwissenschaften, in: Erziehungskunst, April 2007, 376-383.
Schad, Albrecht (2012): On the «Seven Years’ Rhythm», in: Journal of the Pedagogical Section, No. 45, Michaelmas 2012.
Schad, Albrecht (2018): Founding Impulses and the Future of the Waldorf School, in: Journal of the Pedagogical Section No. 63, Easter 2018
Schad, Albrecht (2019): Der Mensch und sein Leib – alles in Entwicklung, in: Medizinisch-pädagogische Konferenz. Heft 90, Nov. 2019, S. 43-71.
Schad, Albrecht (2023): Vom Leben unserer Erde. Verlag Freies Geistesleben.
Schad, Wolfgang (1992): Der Umschwung in der Reifezeit – Lebensprozesse und Seelengeburt. In: Glöckler, M. (Hrsg.): Das Schulkind – Gemeinsame Aufgaben von Arzt und Lehrer. S. 155-175. Verlag am Goetheanum.
Schad, Wolfgang (1994): Erziehung ist Kunst. S. 117. Verlag Freies Geistesleben.
Schad, Wolfgang (2012): Säugetiere und Mensch. Verlag Freies Geistesleben.
Steiner, Rudolf (1907): The education of the child in the light of anthroposophy, transl. by George Adams, (in German GA 34. S. 310)
Steiner, Rudolf (1912): Erfahrungen des Übersinnlichen. Die drei Wege der Seele zu Christus. Vortrag 16.4.1912, GA 143.
Steiner Rudolf (1917): Riddles of the Soul, Mercury Press (in German GA 21, S. 150 ff.)
Steiner Rudolf (1919/1932, 1992): The Foundations of Human Experience, (in German: GA 293, 9. Auflage Rudolf Steiner Verlag: Dornach)
Steiner, Rudolf (1923): Lebendiges Naturerkennen. Intellektueller Sündenfall und spirituelle Sündenerhebung. GA 220. S. 42/43.
Steiner, Rudolf (1974): The essentials of Education, Anthroposophic Press
Steiner Rudolf (1991): Das Schicksalsjahr 1923 in der Geschichte der Anthroposophischen Gesellschaft. GA 259, S. 173f. Rudolf Steiner Verlag.
Steiner, Rudolf (1924): The Kingdom of Childhood, AP, 1995. 7 Lectures, Torquay, 1924. (In German: GA 311. Rudolf Steiner Verlag)
Wiechert, Christof (2020): Solving the Riddle of the Child, Verlag am Goetheanum.
Zdražil, Tomáš (2000): Gesundheitsförderung und Waldorfpädagogik. Dissertation.